← Applying business knowledge to a critical problem

Identifying the cause before proposing a solution

A skill underlying EVERY part of this standard: a solution can only score well if it attacks the cause actually named or implied in the resource, not a generic version of the problem.

The three-step reading discipline

  • 1. READ FOR THE SYMPTOM: what is visibly going wrong (complaints, cancelled orders, a resignation, falling survey scores)?
  • 2. READ FOR THE CAUSE: what does the resource say or imply CAUSED that symptom (an incompatible system, an unconsulted policy change, an unclear leadership structure)?
  • 3. MATCH THE SOLUTION TO THE CAUSE, NOT THE SYMPTOM: a solution that only addresses the visible symptom (apologise, offer a discount, discipline a staff member) without touching the underlying cause will keep producing the same problem.
ℹ

Why this matters more than it first appears

The marking schedule explicitly checks that a proposed solution "addresses the problem" identified earlier in the SAME part — a well-written, sensible-sounding solution that happens to solve a DIFFERENT problem than the one named in the resource will not score well, however good the writing is. Worked example Matching a solution to the correct cause, not the symptom A survey shows customers complaining about "unreliable service" on a wilderness trip. The resource reveals the actual cause was contracting the trip out to unfamiliar guides. Propose a solution matched to the cause. SYMPTOM: customers experienced missing equipment, food shortages, and uncontactable guides. CAUSE (from the resource): management contracted the trip to guides they did not personally know or vet. MATCHED SOLUTION: implement a formal vetting and briefing process for any contracted guide before a trip, rather than simply apologising to the affected customers or offering a discount on their next booking. ✓ The solution targets the ACTUAL cause (unvetted contracting) rather than a generic customer-service gesture that would not stop the same failure recurring on the next trip.

Practice for this standard covers the whole topic — flashcards and quiz.