← Differences in development

Comparing factors, strategies, or indicators against each other

A stronger answer often makes an explicit comparison, rather than presenting one item in isolation.

What a genuine comparison adds

  • Compare a NATURAL factor against a CULTURAL factor for the same case study — which is more significant, and why (a natural constraint can often be overcome with enough investment, whereas a deep-rooted cultural/political factor may resist change for generations).
  • Compare a TOP-DOWN strategy against a BOTTOM-UP one — which better suits the specific case study's circumstances, and why one might work where the other would not.
  • Compare TWO indicators measuring the same case study — where they agree, and where they diverge, and what that divergence itself reveals.
✕

Two separate paragraphs is not the same as a comparison

Writing one paragraph about a natural factor and a separate paragraph about a cultural factor, with no sentence connecting them, describes two things without comparing them. A genuine comparison states which is MORE significant (or how they interact), with a reason — the explicit comparative judgement is what the top grade band rewards. Worked example Comparing a natural and a cultural factor Compare the relative significance of being landlocked (natural) versus a legacy of colonial single-commodity trade (cultural) for a named developing country. STATE BOTH: the country is landlocked, adding transport costs to trade, AND its economy remains heavily dependent on exporting one colonial-era commodity. COMPARE: the colonial trade dependency is arguably MORE significant, because it exposes the entire economy to a single world price the country cannot control, whereas the landlocked cost, while real, is a fixed, known cost that can be partly offset by regional transport agreements. JUSTIFY: a sudden world price crash for the single commodity could devastate government revenue overnight, while the landlocked transport cost changes only gradually. ✓ The explicit comparative judgement (which factor is more significant, and why) is what turns two descriptions into genuine analysis.

Practise just this